When it comes to classic liqueurs, Benedictine is a staple in many bars and kitchens. With its unique blend of 27 herbs and spices, the liqueur adds depth and complexity to cocktails and dishes alike. However, for various reasons, you may find yourself needing a Benedictine substitute. Whether you want to try something new or simply don’t have the liqueur on hand, there are several alternatives that can provide a similar flavor profile. In this post, we’ll explore some of the best Benedictine substitutes and how you can use them.
Flavor Profile of Benedictine Liqueur
Before we delve into substitutes, let’s take a closer look at the flavor profile of Benedictine liqueur. The liqueur is a blend of 27 herbs and spices, including angelica, hyssop, juniper, myrrh, saffron, and cinnamon. It has a sweet, slightly spicy, and herbal flavor that can be described as warm and comforting. Some of the tasting notes include:
The key ingredients in Benedictine are angelica, hyssop, and juniper, which give the liqueur its unique flavor. However, there are several alternatives that can mimic the taste profile of Benedictine.
Here are some of the best substitutes for Benedictine liqueur:
Chartreuse is a French liqueur that is made by Carthusian monks. It is made from a blend of 130 herbs, plants, and flowers, and has a complex flavor profile that is similar to Benedictine. Chartreuse comes in two varieties: green and yellow. The green variety has a stronger flavor and is more herbaceous, while the yellow variety is sweeter and has a milder flavor.
Taste Profile: Herbal, floral, sweet, and complex.
Recipe Ideas: Chartreuse is a great substitute for Benedictine in classic cocktails like the Vieux Carre, Last Word, and Corpse Reviver #2. You can also use it in food recipes like Chartreuse sabayon, which is a custard-like sauce made with egg yolks, sugar, and Chartreuse.
Bénédictine DOM is a modern version of Benedictine that was introduced in the 1930s. It is made from the same 27 herbs and spices as Benedictine but has a slightly different flavor profile. Bénédictine DOM is milder and less sweet than Benedictine, and has a more pronounced citrus flavor.
Taste Profile: Herbal, spicy, citrusy, and less sweet than Benedictine.
Recipe Ideas: Bénédictine DOM is a great substitute for Benedictine in classic cocktails like the Bobby Burns and Benedictine Cocktail. You can also use it in food recipes like Bénédictine shrimp, which is a simple and delicious appetizer made by sautéing shrimp in Bénédictine DOM and butter.
Grand Marnier is a French liqueur that is made from a blend of cognac, bitter oranges, and sugar. It has a sweet and citrusy flavor profile that can be used as a substitute for Benedictine. Grand Marnier is also available in several varieties, including Cordon Rouge, Cuvée du Centenaire, and Quintessence. Each variety has a unique flavor profile and can be used in different ways.
Taste Profile: Sweet, citrusy, and complex.
Recipe Ideas: Grand Marnier is a great substitute for Benedictine in classic cocktails like the Margarita, Sidecar, and Cosmopolitan. You can also use it in food recipes like Grand Marnier soufflé, which is a light and fluffy dessert made with eggs, sugar, flour, and Grand Marnier.
Yellow Chartreuse is a milder version of Chartreuse that is made from a blend of 130 herbs, plants, and flowers. It has a sweeter and less herbaceous flavor than green Chartreuse, making it a great substitute for Benedictine. Yellow Chartreuse is also less expensive than green Chartreuse, making it a more affordable option.
Taste Profile: Herbal, floral, sweet, and milder than green Chartreuse.
Recipe Ideas: Yellow Chartreuse is a great substitute for Benedictine in classic cocktails like the Bijou and Monkey Gland. You can also use it in food recipes like Yellow Chartreuse chicken, which is a simple and flavorful dish made by marinating chicken in Yellow Chartreuse and spices.
Strega is an Italian liqueur that is made from a blend of over 70 herbs and spices. It has a sweet and herbal flavor profile that can be used as a substitute for Benedictine. Strega means “witch” in Italian, and the liqueur is said to have mystical powers that can bring good luck and prosperity.
Taste Profile: Herbal, sweet, and complex.
Recipe Ideas: Strega is a great substitute for Benedictine in classic cocktails like the Yellow Jacket and Vieux Mot. You can also use it in food recipes like Strega risotto, which is a creamy and flavorful dish made with rice, Strega, and Parmesan cheese.
Recipes Using Benedictine Substitutes
Now that you know about some of the best Benedictine substitutes, let’s explore some recipes that you can make with them. Here are some classic and modern cocktails that you can make using Benedictine substitutes:
- The Last Word (Chartreuse)
- Vieux Carre (Chartreuse)
- Bobby Burns (Bénédictine DOM)
- Benedictine Cocktail (Bénédictine DOM)
- Margarita (Grand Marnier)
- Sidecar (Grand Marnier)
- Bijou (Yellow Chartreuse)
- Monkey Gland (Yellow Chartreuse)
- Yellow Jacket (Strega)
- Vieux Mot (Strega)
- The Good Word (Chartreuse and gin)
- Benedictine Martini (Bénédictine DOM and gin)
- Spicy Margarita (Grand Marnier and jalapeño)
- Grand Cosmo (Grand Marnier and cranberry juice)
- Chartreuse Swizzle (Green Chartreuse and lime juice)
- Yellow Bird (Yellow Chartreuse and rum)
- Italian Sour (Strega and lemon juice)
- Strega and Tonic (Strega and tonic water)
These cocktails are easy to make at home and are perfect for entertaining or enjoying a night in. Experiment with different Benedictine substitutes to find your favorite flavor profile and use them in your cocktails and food recipes.
Benedictine is a versatile liqueur that can be used in many classic cocktails and food recipes. However, if you are unable to find Benedictine, or if you are looking for a more affordable option, there are several substitutes that you can use instead. Yellow Chartreuse, Grand Marnier, and Strega are all great Benedictine substitutes that have unique flavor profiles and can be used in a variety of cocktails and food recipes. Experiment with different substitutes to find your favorite and enjoy the complex and delicious flavors of these liqueurs.